Comparing Discovery in Bradford and Frost’s Writings

Subject : Englsih

Question:

Although William Bradford and Robert Frost both explore the theme of “discovery,” what differences do you notice in how the authors relate this theme?

Expert Verified Solution:

When comparing how William Bradford and Robert Frost explore the theme of “discovery,” we notice distinct differences in their approaches and perspectives:

Historical vs. Personal Exploration:

• William Bradford: As a leader of the Plymouth Colony, Bradford’s exploration of “discovery” is deeply rooted in the historical context of early American settlement. His work, “Of Plymouth Plantation,” reflects the physical and spiritual discovery of a new world, emphasizing the challenges, hardships, and divine providence that shaped the Pilgrims’ journey and settlement.
• Robert Frost: In contrast, Frost’s exploration of discovery is often more introspective and personal. His poetry, such as in “The Road Not Taken,” delves into the discovery of self, choices, and the consequences of those choices. Frost’s work is more focused on the internal journey and the metaphorical paths one takes in life.

Optimism vs. Ambiguity:

• Bradford: Bradford’s narrative is one of resilience and faith. The discoveries he writes about are often framed as part of a larger divine plan, with a sense of purpose and optimism despite the hardships faced by the Pilgrims.
• Frost: Frost’s portrayal of discovery is more nuanced and often tinged with ambiguity. The outcomes of the discoveries in his poems are not always clear-cut, leaving room for interpretation and reflection on the complexities of life and the unknowns that come with it.

Collective vs. Individual Discovery:

• Bradford: The theme of discovery in Bradford’s work is communal. It reflects the collective experience of the Pilgrims as they navigate and establish their new world, emphasizing shared values and experiences.
• Frost: Frost’s exploration of discovery is more individualized. His poetry often centers around a solitary figure making a personal journey, highlighting the unique, personal nature of discovery.

These differences highlight how each author brings their unique perspective to the theme of discovery, shaped by their time, experiences, and the purpose of their writing.